Thoughts on the Supreme Court decision on Obamacare

One can’t have a serious health blog and not discuss the Supreme Court decision to uphold most of Obamacare.    My initial reaction was real disappointment — because I truly believe the law is a bad law and bad for the future of our country.   I am not a lawyer and Roberts’ logic seems somewhat tortured, but after reading several legal blogs on the topic — I believe Roberts was sincere and apolitical in his reasoning and I support the outcome and the process.

As I have written previoulsy, the real problem is Obamacare does little to solve the true health care crisis in our country.   Worse, the political dialog regarding Obamacare has done nothing to educate the citizenry about the dysfunctional health system which could have enabled a more sustainable set of solutions.

There are three pillars — Access, Cost and Quality — that are part of any discussion for improving our health care system.   They are all important and intertwined.   Obamacare primarily deals with Access (individual mandate, pre-existing conditions, insurance exchanges etc.) but it does nothing meaningfuj and systematic to improve either Cost or Quality.   The biggest issue in our healthcare system is economic — we are not getting sufficient Value out of our huge healthcare spend (Value = quality of health outcomes – cost over time).   For example, the IOM and other experts believe that 30+% of our $2.2 trillion of spend is wasted — that is $750B annually!!!    The only sustainable solution to increasing Access is to make health care more economically affordable, which requires an improvement in Value, which requires changing the way the system is organized and incentivized.  Obamacare does not do this and in fact, probably makes things worse re: affordability and sustainability.   Increased Access to insurance within the current framework obviously does not drive or improve affordability — or we would not have the unsustainable health care cost trend we do.

I will develop further the themes of Value and affordability in future blogs.  This WSJ op-ed is a good start.   My strongly held personal belief is that free enterprise, marketplaces and competition amongst providers and payers is much more likely to improve Value and affordability than more government rules and bureaucracy.

Which leads me to my biggest concern resulting from the Obamacare political debate…which is; is our country headed more toward socialism vs. our traditional strength of ‘free markets and free peoples’.    As Chief Justice Roberts noted in his opinion — it is not the job of the Supreme Court to “protect the people from the consequences of their political choices.”

Nike and Garmin — liberate your data!

I finally broke down and bought a GPS computer for my bike to track my rides and improve performance.    I love it and the ability to track/share my rides on Strava.     So then naturally, I wanted the same capabilties for my runs — but I chose the Nike GPS sportwatch instead of a Garmin one because of better usability.    But of course the Nike data can only be uploaded with the Nikeplus website and at least from what I can figure out — one can’t export the file elsewhere (either from the device or the website).     And neither set of devices are HealthVault enabled….which means I can’t easily utilize the results of my training with my HealthVault apps, like or

I get I’m a bit of a gear/gadget head.    But personal health devices work — they motivate and engage consumers.   And it is clear there will be a lot more of them coming for fitness, for specific disease conditions and for lifestyle purposes.   For them to really have an impact, they must liberate their data and make it available to other applications to use and share.    As a user, I don’t want to have a silo’ed relationship with each type of device I use.   I want them to contribute to a wholistic view of my health and for me to be able to decide how to leverage and share the data.

Come on device manufacturers and consumer products companies — continue innovating with cool new products and apps — but please liberate MY data!